[Peter Orchard]

I understand you haven´t read this book yet, ODM?
You should perhaps reserve judgement (and the vitriol) until you have read it.

One thing you may learn about critiquing a book you haven´t yet read is you look like a fool when discussing with those who have read it.

The book is a good book and a great read but it explodes the flimsy myth of Clough as legend. My opinion is something you´ll have to live with.