I looked at the side yesterday and its no real surprise they are where they are.
Green - a Championship level keeper IMO. One belting save with his head yesterday though.
Neill - a middle of the road EPL right back on a massive salary. Would rather play for West Ham, and the money, than Liverpool.
Ferdinand - believes his own press, not a patch on his brother at that age.
Upson - injury prone centre half. Who cost £7.5m.
Davenport - Championship level centre half.
Konchesky - middle of the road EPL left back.
Bowyer - a shadow the Leeds player he was. Wouldn't be picked for any semi decent EPL side nowadays.
Quashie - Championship level midfield player.
Noble - hard to blame a young lad with a handful of apperances, a lot to ask for him to try and dig you out of a hole.
Etherington - squad player at best in EPL, probably a Championship level player.
Harewood - Championship level striker
Tevez - must look about and think WTF.
Zamora - squad player at best in EPL.
Conclusion - when you have so many Championship level players in your side, added to a bunch of mediocre middle of the road EPL players it seems pretty obvious your going to end up in the Championship.
How a player like Mascherano couldn't get a game amongst that lot I will never know. He looked decent at the World Cup yet Curbishley replaces him with Nigel Quashie.

Benitez obviously rates him enough to take him to Liverpool.
They had a good season last season and there was the potential to build on it this season. A couple of good wide players, they had already added Tevez and Mascherano and a couple of good defenders and they would have improved.